On August 19, 2010 in the early morning local time in Iraq (evening of August 18 in the U.S.), the last battalion of the 4th Stryker Brigade, 2nd Infantry division, was on its way home. They traveled in Stryker combat vehicles in a convoy to Kuwait where they had their documents checked and their possessions checked for contraband as soon as they crossed the Kuwait border. There are a few thousand more combat troops who will be leaving over the next several days.
Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy
The convoy proceeded to Camp Virginia in Kuwait, and from there, military personnel will fly home to the U.S. Their retrievable equipment will be loaded aboard ships to the U.S. A great deal of the equipment our military brought to Iraq will remain there.
These are the last of the combat troops. The first combat troops to leave began withdrawing about a year ago.
Most wars in modern times, meaning ever since the end of World War II, are often entered into for political reasons and are ended or drawn down by political agreements or decisions, not whether we won or lost a military victory.
The only wars we’ve fought during my lifetime (born 1960) that were predicated by attacks of an aggressor are the Gulf war in 1991 and the Afghanistan war after we were attacked on American soil by al-Qaeda on 9/11/2001.
The end of the first Gulf war was decided when Saddam Hussein and his troops were driven out of Kuwait back to Baghdad. Some U.S. forces remained behind to enforce sanctions against Iraq and keep Iraq within its borders.
The only military victory I can foresee in the Afghanistan war is the capture or killing of Osama bin Laden, and perhaps his next highest ranking subordinate. Leaving Afghanistan won’t happen until NATO forces reach specific goals, like the Afghan army and police can handle security without our help, and/or many towns and cities have reestablished government and services, and provide a better choice than the Taliban.
Or, we may reach our target deadline and pull out before “conditions on the ground” criteria are fully met. The fact is we can’t hold the Afghans’ hand forever. They have to step up and take charge at some point. Us leaving will force them to do so, which is what is happening in Iraq right now.
Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy
Even though this is a politically agreed upon troop withdrawal, it isn’t time for politics. It’s time to be thankful that our brave men and women are coming home, and to remember that 4,415 U.S. troops didn’t make it home from Iraq alive.
This brings to my mind the end of the Vietnam War, and that my parents kept us home from school that morning in 1975 to watch it on TV. My dad was in the Navy then, and he called his commanding officer to get permission to stay home with us to discuss the significance and gravity of that event. We were teenagers and they felt it was very important that we understand what was happening and why.
It’s time to remember that we have a large number of battle-hardened war veterans reentering civilian life who will need care, our support and our help. We the people need to help make sure our veterans are getting what they need, whether it be their GI bill benefits for college, job placement assistance, or medical and psychiatric treatment from the VA.
It’s time to remember that some of these troops will be retrained, re-equipped and redeployed to Afghanistan in as few as 6 months.
It’s also time to remember that 50,000 U.S. troops will remain in Iraq to assist and support the Iraqi army and police, and to work with the U.S. State Department to rebuild a successful Iraqi government and society. We are pulling combat troops out without Iraq having established a fully functional government, which I will discuss in another article. Iraq is still a very dangerous place. Combat may be over, but the possibility of violence and more American deaths is very real.
Operation Iraqi Freedom won’t officially end until the ceremony on August 31, 2010. The mission then changes to Operation New Dawn, one of training and support with “non-combat” troops. That’s kind of an oxymoron to me. A military troop is by definition capable of combat. The U.S. State Department will take over, and the Defense Department will end primary control of non-combat operations.
Iraq war, Keith Olbermann, Lawrence O'Donnell, Operation Iraqi Freedom, Operation New Dawn, Rachel Maddow, Richard Engel NBC Chief Foreign Correspondent, U.S. Forces draw down
August 25th, 2010 at 1:07 pm
Sherri – I watched that whole progression as each huge truck went through the gate and cried.
What amazing technology NBC has. I guess no one else has it.
Waiting to cry again when we leave Afganistan.
Please God. Soon. I don’t want to lose one more life in an unwillable war.
More and more it is looking like the enemy we must monitor is living next door to us.
More intelligence here. I don’t care if they tap my phone. If they want to hear conversations with my sister, they are welcome.
Corinne Edwards´s last [type] ..A WOMAN WITHOUT A MAN – Introduction – what it’s all about
August 26th, 2010 at 1:10 am
Corinne, I cried, too.
What shocks me is there is almost no talk or coverage of our soldiers coming home from Iraq. You’re the only person I know outside my family who watched.
It was a much bigger deal when we left Vietnam. It was on all the networks, all 3 that is.
I don’t know why other networks haven’t invested in the same technology NBC has. It’s just a satellite link on a gyroscope and it works like the GPS system in your car. The GPS tracks the satellite so it can stay in communication with it. It was new technology in 2003. It’s not that new today. Cell phones work similarly. They track towers on Earth instead of satellites in space, but it’s the same idea.
I hope if the time-table isn’t kept for Afghanistan that Congress will enforce it by cutting funding. Conditions on the ground should only matter if we find terrorist cells active within Afghanistan. Then we’ll have a counterterrorism strategy we can win quickly. Those are basically search-and-destroy missions. In those, our war tactics work well; find them and kill all of them. What will make COIN work is if Gen. Pataeus works well with our diplomatic corps to do nation-building while the military provides security and training. Once the Afghan army and police are up to muster, we can draw down troops.
Our draw down is supposed to begin in July of 2011. It won’t end in July 2011 because the logistics of that huge a troop movement is complex. It took a year to draw all combat troops out of Iraq with about 4,000 leaving each week since July of 2009, when combat troops were ordered to remain on their bases unless requested to help the Iraqi forces.
It’s logistically difficult to draw down our troops because we have more deployed today than we did storming the beaches of Normandy in World War II. We don’t think about the sheer numbers of troops involved. It’s a rather small portion of our population, but in numbers, it’s huge.
I’m pretty sure some security agency is busy reading our emails, listening to our phone calls, and essentially violating our privacy in many ways we don’t know about. The health insurance companies have as good a records on us as the IRS, so the security folks should have us well covered. If they want to listen in on my rather routine life, they can go ahead. So long as we retain the right of habeas corpus and the rest of our constitutional rights…